Partnering with the public is a system imperative
The findings of the Muckamore Abbey Hospital Public Inquiry were sobering reading for the Health and Social Care (HSC) system. They require us to take a different approach to how we engage and partner with the public Ruth Sutherland, Chair of the Patient Client Council, writes.
At Muckamore, extremely vulnerable individuals with mental health problems and learning disabilities, many of whom were non-verbal, were subjected to shocking abuse and neglect over many years.
Throughout the long and arduous process of inquiry the families acted with extreme dignity, determination and love to ensure the experiences of their loved ones were finally acknowledged and the abuse they suffered was fully uncovered. There is inherent risk in the delivery of health and social care, but when things go wrong it is incumbent on the system to learn and do better, not to repeat failure. When things go catastrophically wrong, as they did in Muckamore, there is imperative for system change.
As the Department of Health (DoH) and the HSC system work to respond, the PCC considers that some fundamentals need to be at the forefront of all our thinking, to ensure this really is a watershed moment.
It is clear from the inquiry’s findings that a core reason for the failure to act was because individuals, organisations, and oversight systems did not hear or listen to the voices and concerns of patients and families, and with sufficient weight.
The public inquiry recognised that “patients and families are experts by experience and are sometimes better placed than staff or health experts to comment”. Powerful testimony showed that individuals and families tried to raise concerns but were not listened to. There were multiple, persistent and well-documented warning signs, but organisations and the system failed to ‘join the dots’.
Listening to and hearing people and families’ experiences should be the first line of defence when safeguarding vulnerable people. Muckamore demonstrates that having your voice heard by the right people, in the face of power imbalances and complex systems and structures, can be extremely difficult.
Appropriately addressing these weaknesses requires a significant and systemic change of approach and culture. At the PCC, we have set out a vision for such a change which would see the development of a relational, partnership-based approach between the public, HSC staff, organisations, and their governance and oversight systems.
People as Partners calls for us to recognise the public as an asset and be willing to share power with them. It requires shifting from a ‘do for’ or ‘to’ mentality, to a ‘doing with’ approach. A baseline for partnering with the public means systematically listening to their concerns, needs, and ideas, and taking them seriously. The potential benefits include enhancing public health and helping people stay well, improving patient safety, and developing and delivering more effective and efficient services which better meet community needs.
The good news is that the HSC system has embraced this vision and has started to move in this direction. A People as Partners approach was adopted as a necessary shift to deliver the Minister’s Reset Plan at the NICON Conference in 2025. Developing a Northern Ireland-specific strategic framework on partnering with the public, is a key ask from members in NICON’s 2027 election briefing. DoH has initiated a Northern Ireland wide conversation with the public through its ‘This is our Health’ initiative. The Neighbourhood Model of Care is examining the mechanisms needed to deliver more joined up and systemic engagement with the public. And, the PCC has recently published a thought paper on the need for regional independent advocacy services and what this might look like.
These are welcome developments, however, to deliver the shift needed, in the face of the significant financial and service delivery pressures, which are severely impacting both the public and staff, we need to bring intentional system-wide focus to this work. To go fast is to go alone; if we want to go further, we must go together. In fulfilling our statutory functions of representing the public in Health and Social Care and propelled by the moral imperative that people have both a right and a duty to participate in their health and health and social care, PCC will continue to provide bold leadership in this area until we are all truly partners.

Find out more about PCC’s work across independent advocacy, participation, and policy influence:
T: 0800 917 0222
E: info@pcc-ni.net
W: www.pcc-ni.net




