Health Report

A lost decade for health transformation

October 2026 marked 10 years since the publication of Systems, Not Structures: Changing Health and Social Care, by World Health Organization expert and professor Raphael Bengoa. agendaNi examines the lost decade for Northern Ireland’s health service and how political turmoil has prevented progress.

The central component of Raphael Bengoa’s proposals was the amalgamation of certain services. The report said in 2016: “The stark options facing the HSC system are either to resist change and see services deteriorate to the point of collapse over time, or to embrace transformation and work to create a modern, sustainable service that is properly equipped to help people stay as healthy as possible and to provide them with the right type of care when they need it.”

Talk of radical reform to the hospital network first emerged in 2001, when the Maurice Hayes review recommended, amongst other things, reducing the total number of hospitals.

The 2011 Compton Review included a recommendation to cut the number of acute hospitals from 10 to five, while in 2014, the Donaldson report suggested closing some local hospitals in recognition that expertise was being too thinly spread across Northern Ireland’s network.

Bengoa’s report was the fourth health review in less than a quarter of a century that suggested cutting or changing the number of acute hospitals, but change to date has been piecemeal.

Changes to date

The changes implemented since the publication of the report have been minimal and have been cast aside by significant public opposition, particularly in rural areas. Attempts to move services from various hospitals have been met with protests. Transformation changes have also been hampered by the ongoing budget crisis and calls by the UK Government for public spending reductions in Northern Ireland.

Mike Nesbitt’s leadership of the Department of Health presented arguably the first opportunity in the absence of political crisis or pandemics to spearhead some of the recommendations in the Bengoa report. The report’s recommendations received unanimous support from the then-five Executive parties in 2016 which was subsequently reiterated in New Decade, New Approach in 2020.

In January 2026, Nesbitt took the first steps in reform when he sought to move emergency general surgery (EGS) services from Causeway Hospital to Antrim Area Hospital. The Northern Health Trust previously recommended that EGS should only be provided at one of its hospital sites. It is understood the Department was still waiting for a final recommendation to come from the Minister.

At a town hall meeting regarding the issue in August 2026, which Nesbitt was unable to attend, his party leader Jon Burrows MLA went in his place and contradicted his minister, outlining his opposition to the removal of EGS from Causeway Hospital, saying: “Emergency surgery must remain at the Causeway Hospital and it should be built up, not run down and that is my position and it is not for negotiation.”

This prompted Nesbitt to resign as Health Minister, saying in his resignation letter that he was unhappy to have to “discover the leader’s view of issues under my purview by having to monitor the media”.

Other examples of consolidation include moving services from South West Acute Hospital to Altnagelvin and potentially moving maternity services from Daisy Hill to Craigavon.

Political turmoil

The publication of the Bengoa report was swiftly followed by the collapse of the Executive in January 2017, after Martin McGuinness resigned as deputy First Minister. Stormont subsequently remained down until January 2020.

Upon the Executive being formed, former Ulster Unionist Party leader Robin Swann MP was appointed as the Minister of Health. He could not have picked a worse time to assume the role, as, far from leading transformation, Swann was to preside over Northern Ireland’s response to a pandemic which would plunge the world into lockdown.

The Covid-19 pandemic resulted in at least 7.2 million deaths worldwide and consumed the Department of Health’s priorities immediately upon Swann’s assuming office right until Stormont collapsed again in 2022 over the DUP’s objections to the Northern Ireland Protocol.

Once again, the Executive stayed down for a lengthy period, only returning in February 2024. Swann returned to the role later that month, only to depart again upon his election to the House of Commons in May 2024. It was then run by Nesbitt until he resigned in August 2026.

Robbie Butler MLA has been in post since, but he will only be in office until May 2027 when the Assembly is up for re-election. This means that by May 2027 (if an Executive is even formed), the Department of Health will have had five ministers over the 10-and-a-half years since the Bengoa report was published, and with five of those years having been spent with no Minister at the helm.

Even among the five-and-a-half years where a minister was in post, two of those were spent with a global pandemic being the priority. As a result, progress has been little to none and strategic, long-term thinking has been abandoned in place of populism.

Despite the common link, the Bengoa report makes no recommendation on the closure of hospitals. While it proposes that some services are consolidated in larger hospitals, sometimes known as proposed ‘super hospitals’, the agenda is backed up by studies showing that transformation will ensure greater value for money and better health outcomes for the general public.

Within the current system, Northern Ireland’s patients have been paying the price and the current system is failing to deliver value for money. In 2024/25 spending on health per person in Northern Ireland was the second highest in the UK, compared to England, Scotland, and Wales.

Despite this, waiting time figures highlight the significant pressures facing Northern Ireland’s health service. In 2025/26, just 43.3 per cent of A&E patients were admitted, transferred, or discharged within four hours, compared with 61.1 per cent in England and 63.9 per cent in Wales. Meanwhile, 17.3 per cent of A&E attendances lasted over 12 hours.

Cancer waiting times make for similarly bleak reading, as only 28.4 per cent of patients in Northern Ireland began treatment within 62 days of an urgent referral between April and June 2026, compared with 73.6 per cent in Scotland, 71.2 per cent in England, and 57.1 per cent in Wales.

Interestingly, despite the fact that some sections of the health service in the Republic are privatised, public spending per head of population was higher than any part of the UK in 2024. Furthermore, there is a significant difference in healthy life expectancy, which is 7.3 years higher for men and 7.1 years higher for women in the Republic.

Towards an all-island health service?

In 2025, Sinn Féin published a paper which received little attention, The Case for an Irish National Health and Care Service: A discussion paper. The paper reveals that health is going to be a priority policy item for Sinn Féin going forward.

In the last two d’Hondt allocations in 2020 and 2024, the Department of Health has been passed over by the large parties and has been the final choice, meaning that the Ulster Unionist Party has – off and on again – controlled the Department since 2020.

The Sinn Féin paper proposes, as the name suggests, an all-island national health service. The report says: “The Shared Island Unit should develop detailed costings for implementing the Sláintecare and Bengoa reports and also develop costed proposals for integrating the health systems in the north and the south as a single universal healthcare system.

“Both these reports should be considered as a potential roadmap when designing a new Health and Care Service.”

The prospect of the proposals being thrust into policy received momentum in October 2026 when the party surprisingly announced that Fermanagh and South Tyrone MP Pat Cullen, the former head of the Royal College of Nursing (RCN), was to run in the Assembly election in Belfast South and Mid Down.

Politically, the DUP managed to strategically outmanoeuvre Sinn Féin when picking Executive departments in 2024, surprising its republican rivals by opting not to take charge of either the Department of Finance or Department for the Economy. In choosing Education and Communities, the DUP sought to utilise the respective departments’ powers on the Irish language and Casement Park and has done so with success.

There is belief within Sinn Féin that taking control of the Department of Health could allow it to reset the health agenda on an all-island basis, with health currently a significant source of contention in the debate on Northern Ireland’s constitutional future.

Whether this comes to pass or not, it would mark a change of Health being the least desirable department for parties to take control of and would certainly give it a form of strategic vision which has been sorely lacking, as well as potential new cash if the proposals on Shared Island Unit funding come to pass.

Show More
Back to top button