Treated as a witness, not a victim
Sexual assault survivors repeatedly explain how the courts in Northern Ireland see them as a source of evidence, rather than a victim of a crime. Seven years on from the Gillen Review, the reforms we were once promised are still incomplete.
If you were to ask people today what they thought a courtroom is for, the most likely response would be justice: protection for those who have been harmed, answers for the loved ones of victims. However, victims of sexual violence in Northern Ireland tell a different story, a story that removes the victim from the centre of the case. They are a prosecution’s key witness, expected to deliver a perfect account of the worst trauma that they have survived, under pressure, in front of strangers.
However, this problem starts long before a courtroom. Many survivors of sexual violence describe disbelief or indifference once they have come forward. This often deters sexual crimes from being reported in the first place. For those who do report, few of these cases even make it to a jury. A Criminal Justice Inspection report in 2018 found that conviction rates for rape and sexual offences in Northern Ireland were the lowest in the UK. We cannot assume that victims will come forward by default when the system works against victims from the outset.
Delays are also a contributing factor when it comes to a victim’s experience in the courts. Figures reported in April 2026 showed sexual offence cases taking an average of 630 days to conclude, almost two years of revisiting trauma while daily life is expected to continue as normal. Trial dates are often set and then pushed back with little notice. This can create a cycle of preparing for mental torment and then restarting the process all over again.
Cross examination comes next, when victims are expected to give a coherent and chronological account of their trauma, despite trauma’s ability to fragment memory. Evidence of a complainant’s sexual history can be raised in the courtroom, and rape myths about how a ‘real’ victim behaves can be played to a jury’s assumptions. While screens and video links can limit what a complainant has to face, questioning is still live and confrontational, often years after the event. Some victims describe the cross examination as, at times, more painful than the crime itself.
Former Lord Justice of Appeal John Gillen reviewed the courts system for sexual violence cases in 2019 and made 253 recommendations. This included the pre-recorded cross-examination away from the courtroom, measures to counter rape myths, and free independent legal advice. Some of these recommendations have landed. However, the Sexual Offences Legal Advisers scheme is still a pilot, and has only been extended until March 2027, and the advice stops when the trial starts. Pre-recorded cross examinations have been used in England and Wales for years, yet it sits in planning stage in Northern Ireland.
Victims of sexual violence in Northern Ireland are still being treated as an afterthought. Reform has been promised before, yet victims in Northern Ireland rarely see meaningful change. Gillen’s test was whether a victim could make it through the courts system without being harmed again. Seven years on, many still cannot.
Northern Ireland has the opportunity to reform the courts and better the lives of those who have survived sexual violence, we just need an injection of political will, and a commitment to what has been promised to us since the Gillen Review in 2019.
Pearse O’Neill is project manager of the Athrú Project which aims to raise awareness about violence and injustice in Northern Ireland and calls for the establishment of a Minister for Women’s Safety and Health.




