A tale of two budgets

While the first UK Budget under Andy Burnham’s premiership offers small relief to struggling households but little improvement in quality of life, eight months into the financial year, the Executive has yet to agree a budget, risking spending restrictions which threaten essential public services.
Announced on 28 October 2026, Chancellor John Healey’s cautious first Budget contains a range of smaller measures aimed at easing the cost-of-living crisis.
This caution reflects the challenging state of the UK economy. The Office for Budget Responsibility’s (OBR) economic and fiscal outlook report for October 2026 states: “The UK’s economic and fiscal position remains very challenging. Since 2008, repeated adverse shocks have contributed to persistently weak GDP growth and elevated levels of government borrowing.”
Among the measures intended to ease financial pressures are UK-wide increases to the National Living Wage and National Minimum Wage.
From 1 April 2027, the National Living Wage will increase by 3.9 per cent to £13.21 per hour, with the National Minimum Wage also rising by 3.9 per cent to £11.27 per hour for 18 to 20-year-olds and to £8.31 per hour for 16 to 17-year-olds and eligible apprentices.
The Budget extends the 5p per litre cut in fuel duty to 1 July 2027 and cuts the VAT rate on domestic electricity from 5 per cent to zero until July 2027, reducing the annual price cap by £50.
Tariffs on over 100 food products are also removed, which, alongside previous tariff suspensions, will save households up to £21 annually.
Several announcements have particular significance for Northern Ireland with the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland, Chris Bryant MP stating: “This Budget will give families and businesses in Northern Ireland more financial breathing space.”
The removal of the 4 per cent tariff on kerosene is especially relevant, as 61 per cent of households in the region use heating oil in their homes.
Queen’s University Belfast’s CSIT Cyber AI Hub has been allocated £7.5 million to support the development of cybersecurity technologies that protect businesses and critical infrastructure.
The most significant announcement for Northern Ireland was an additional £270 million allocated for public services, with £131 million available this year.
This package includes funding for a one-off £100 payment to help eligible lower-income households with their energy costs.
The payment mirrors a scheme in England supporting up to 20 million households, with the equivalent funding provided to all the UK’s devolved governments.
Executive Budget impasse
However, Northern Ireland is currently unable to avail of this funding because the Executive has not agreed a budget eight months into the financial year.
Without an agreed budget, Executive spending is restricted to 95 per cent of the previous year’s allocation for each department.
This impasse long predates the UK Budget and stems from prolonged disagreements over public service funding.
In July 2025, the UK Government’s Spending Review provided Northern Ireland with a three-year funding settlement covering 2026/27 to 2028/29, allowing the Executive to agree a multi-year budget.
However, this settlement included a limited funding increase. The block grant would rise by £400 million annually from £18.4 billion in 2025/26, an average annual real terms growth of 0.4 per cent for resource spending and 0.7 per cent for capital spending.
In January 2026, Finance Minister John O’Dowd MLA published draft budget proposals covering the three years. These were rejected by the other Executive ministers, who argued that the funding was insufficient to meet the financial pressures facing their departments.
In this draft budget for 2026/27, only four departments would have received modest increases in their budgets: education, health, justice, and infrastructure.
With no agreement reached by April 2026, the Executive entered the financial year without a budget.
The Executive subsequently sought additional Westminster funding, with ministers arguing that parity in funding arrangements with the other devolved regions would remove the financial pressures blocking agreement.
A June 2026 report by the Northern Ireland Fiscal Council found that if the region were funded above the level of assessed need, as in Scotland or Wales, it could receive an additional £1 billion to £3.5 billion annually.
The UK Government refused, stating that the Executive had received a substantial funding settlement and needed to make difficult decisions about its spending.
The Treasury’s Open Book Review of Northern Ireland Executive Budget, published in May 2026, identified several potential avenues for reducing spending.
It stated that reducing the civil service to the equivalent relative size of the English system would save approximately £400 million annually and a household water charge of around £465 annually per property could generate a further £357 million each year for public services.
UK Government negotiations
Upon his appointment in July 2026, Bryant began talks with the Executive to end the impasse. On 7 September 2026, the Executive was offered an additional £350 million annually over three years but the parties rejected this offer, stating it was insufficient to meet the Executive’s budgetary needs.
On 10 September 2026, the UK Government increased its package, with Bryant describing it as the “final offer”. The £1.5 billion package includes:
- £1.25 billion extra funding for the Executive over three years;
- £150 million for public services;
- £100 million for social housing; and
- £75 million to address fraud and error in the benefit system.
The Executive parties again criticised this as insufficient, remaining united on the call for more funding from Westminster.
The UK Government also refused the Executive’s request to ‘front-load’ this money and allow a large portion of it to be spent this year.
Negotiations continued in November 2026 with Bryant understood to have set conditions on any budget deal, including a commitment to raise an additional £200 million in 2027/28 and 2028/29.
These talks ended without an agreement. An increasingly frustrated Bryant said that he is exploring contingency measures to allow him to pass a budget bill if no deal can be reached but would only do so if directly asked by the Executive.
He stated that the deadline before he must do this is January 2027 when the Executive departments will run out of money under the 95 per cent budget rules that they are operating under.
Speaking after the discussions on 5 November 2026, Bryant said: “They really have to take me seriously when I say there is no more money.”
Following unsuccessful discussions on 6 November, O’Dowd said: “Unless the British Government changes tack in terms of fairness and sustainability of funding here, we are always going to run into these challenges in delivering our public services, sustaining them, and growing our economy.”




